This recent season, I was caught in congested traffic on the sweltering streets of Marseille. At a crossing, my friend in the passenger seat advised a right turn toward a renowned spot for fish soup. Yet, the navigation app on my phone commanded us to continue straight. Weary and overheated, I heeded the algorithm's directive. Minutes later, we were stuck at a roadwork site.
A seemingly trivial event, perhaps. But one that encapsulates a central question of our era, where technology touches nearly every facet of our lives: whom do we trust more – other people and our personal instincts, or the machine?
The Enlightenment's Promise and A Contemporary Backslide
The renowned German philosopher Immanuel Kant famously described the Enlightenment as "man's release from its self-inflicted nonage." This immaturity, he wrote, "is the inability to use one's own understanding without direction from another." For ages, that guiding "other" for society was often the priest, the king, or the feudal lord – figures claiming to speak for divine will. To explain natural events like volcanic eruptions, people looked for explanations in religion. In organizing the social world, from commerce to matters of the heart, faith served as the primary guide.
“Sapere aude!” or “Have courage to use your own understanding!”
Kant maintained that humans always possessed the capacity for reason. They simply lacked the confidence to use it. With upheavals in America and France, a fresh era arrived: logic would supplant superstition, and the human mind, liberated from authority, would become the engine of advancement and a more ethical world.
Now, 250 years later, one might wonder if we are quietly regressing into a form of dependency. An app dictating a driving route is just one example. Artificial intelligence threatens to become our contemporary authority – a unseen overseer that steers our choices and behaviors. We risk ceding the hard-won courage to reason for ourselves – and now, not to deities or rulers, but to computer programs.
The Swift Adoption and Subtle Dangers of AI Dependence
ChatGPT debuted a mere three years ago, and yet a global survey found that an overwhelming majority of respondents had used AI in the preceding half-year. Whether contemplating a breakup or choosing a candidate, individuals are looking to machines for counsel. Research suggests a large majority of user queries relate to non-work topics. Even more striking than our reliance on AI for advice is what occurs when we allow it speak for us. Writing is now among the most common uses for generative AI, just behind practical requests. The celebrated American author Joan Didion once remarked, “I write purely to discover what I am thinking.” What occurs when we stop composing? Do we lose that path?
Alarmingly, some evidence hints the outcome may be yes. A study conducted by the Massachusetts Institute of Technology used electroencephalography to observe the mental engagement of essay writers who had access to AI, traditional search engines, or no aids. Those who could use AI showed the lowest brain activity and had difficulty quoting their own work. Perhaps most troubling was that over time, participants in the AI group grew increasingly reliant, copying large sections of text.
“Inertia and fear,” Kant wrote, “are the reasons why so great a proportion of men … stay in lifelong immaturity.”
Of course, AI's appeal stems from its efficiency. It saves time, reduces effort and – critically – offers a novel way to offload accountability. In his 1941 book, Escape from Freedom, the German psychoanalyst Erich Fromm argued that the appeal of authoritarianism could be partly explained by a human tendency to surrender personal freedom in exchange for the comforting security of obedience. AI presents a digital avenue for relinquishing the burden of having to think and choose.
The Opacity Dilemma: Faith Over Reason
AI's primary draw is its ability to accomplish things beyond human capability – sifting through vast datasets at unprecedented speed. Stuck in the car in Marseille, this was, ultimately, why I chose to trust the app over my friend (a choice she interpreted as an affront). With access to all the data, certainly the app must know best – or so I believed.
The core issue is that AI is a black box. It generates answers, but not always fostering human comprehension. We cannot fully grasp the process behind its decisions – including its creators admit this. Nor can we verify its reasoning against transparent standards. So when we follow AI's advice, we are not being led by logic. We are back in the domain of faith. In dubio pro machina: when in doubt, side with the machine – that may become our future guiding principle.
Using Without Losing: The Critical Balance
AI can be a formidable ally for mankind in scientific pursuit. It can aid in medical research, free us from "bullshit jobs", or manage taxes – work that demand little thought and are unfulfilling. All to the good. But Kant and his contemporaries did not advocate for enlightenment just so humans could optimize chores or have extra free time. Critical thinking was not just about efficiency – it was a discipline of freedom and human self-determination.
Human thought is often chaotic and fallible, but it compels us to debate, to question, to challenge concepts – and to acknowledge the boundaries of our own understanding. It builds self-reliance, both personally and as a society. For Kant, the use of reason was never only about information; it was about empowering people to become agents of their own destinies, and to resist control. It was about creating a moral community grounded in the shared principle of reason and debate, rather than blind belief.
With all the advantages AI brings, the paramount challenge is this: how can we harness its promise of advanced capability without undermining human rationality, the bedrock of the Enlightenment and of free societies itself? That may be one of the central dilemmas of our time. It is a question we would do well not to outsource to the machine.